Creative Commons License

After the roof collapsed due to water damage, the fifth, sixth, and 7th floors of 57-59 Sumner Street were vacated due to uninhabitable conditions. Signs detailing the city's order are shown on on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: Sandy Battulga / CT Mirror

Hartford officials have asked the State Attorney’s Office to pursue criminal charges against a “problem landlord,” Shlomo “Sam” Sarot, accusing him of violating state building code.

“This landlord has been subject to many orders of the housing division, the building code division, and has failed to comply with those orders,” said Judith Rothschild, the city’s deputy director of development services, at a press conference on Tuesday.

Sarot lives in Woodmere, N.Y., but owns five properties in Hartford, according to city officials. Sarot was on Mayor Arunan Arulampalam’s December 2025 “problem landlord” list for issues of mice and cockroach infestations, non-working sinks and excessive heat.

Residents at one of Sarot’s buildings, at 57-59 Sumner St., told The Connecticut Mirror that they’ve been dealing with cockroach and mice infestations, among other problems, ever since Sarot took over the building in July 2025. Rothschild said open violations exist at other Sarot-owned buildings, but 57-59 Sumner St. is “the worst of them at this point.”

Several residents at 57-59 Sumner Street don’t keep any food in their cabinets because mice keep raiding their supplies, pictured here on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: Sandy Battulga / CT Mirror

Several residents told the CT Mirror that they can’t keep any food in their cabinets because mice consistently get into the products. As such, they have resorted to ordering food every day.

“Everyone’s still having issues with mice. I don’t have anything in my cabinet. I don’t cook in my pots and pans,” resident Natori Mitchell told CT Mirror on Tuesday. “I’m a whole diabetic. I’m supposed to eat salad and fruit and everything, supposed to cut it up on the counter. You can’t do anything like that if there’s mice droppings everywhere. I have to put aside $30, $40 dollars just so me and my daughter can go eat. Unhealthy. It’s just not fair.”

Her daughter, Ariya Howington, said she sometimes feels “stuff tap on me.

“I think there’s like bugs crawling on me,” the 8-year-old said.

In an emailed response to the CT Mirror, Sarot said the city’s decision to refer him to the State Attorney’s Office “came as a surprise.”

“We have been working with City inspectors to address the building’s conditions and have repeatedly requested clarification and another meeting,” he wrote. “Despite follow-up attempts, that meeting has not been arranged.”

Mitchell has lived in the building since 2021, but said the previous owners maintained the building well. It was only when Sarot took over that she began experiencing major problems.

In addition to vermin infestations, city officials also said the building hasn’t had a working elevator since June. Also, over the July 4th weekend this past summer, the roof collapsed due to water damage. Arulampalam said Sarot hired an “unlicensed contractor” to fix the issue and the contractor ended up doing more damage, which led to the fifth, sixth, and seventh floors of the building becoming unlivable. As such, the city helped pay for tenants on those floors to relocate to other housing.

A dead cockroach and mice droppings decorate the floor of one resident’s apartment on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: Sandy Battulga / CT Mirror

The mayor said the city “made a number of demands” to Sarot to fix the problems in the building over the past four months, including suspending his rental license in October, but Sarot has not fixed the building violations or paid any associated fees or liens.

Violating state building code is a misdemeanor, according to Rothschild. That means if the state attorney decides to pursue legal action for violating that code and the landlord is found guilty, the maximum penalty he could face is between $200 and $1,000 in fines, six months in jail or both.

Rothschild said the state attorney now has to review the city’s filing and decide whether to pursue legal action. Rothschild was formerly a state housing prosecutor and said that this kind of legal action is “common” in her experience, but she did not say how often Hartford has pursued this kind of action against landlords.

Several remaining tenants told the CT Mirror that they want to move out and have tried communicating with Sarot about the infestations they’re facing and other problems in the building but the problems persist.

“The absolute need to relocate depends on the severity of the conditions. If there is severe infestation, then relocation is possible,” Rothschild said. “At this point, we have not yet ordered any vacates for the floors based on just that.”

Regarding the mice and cockroach infestations, Sarot told the CT Mirror that he “promptly arranged professional extermination” after learning of the tenants’ complaints, “followed by treatments every two weeks.”

Sarot also wrote that efforts to replace the broken elevator “have begun” but he doesn’t have a “firm completion date” yet.

But several tenants of the building say exterminators have not visited their units. Mice droppings, dead mice, and numerous dead cockroaches were evident in multiple apartment units and in the apartment building’s stairwell.