Free Daily Headlines :

  • COVID-19
  • Vaccine Info
  • Money
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Health
  • Justice
  • More
    • Environment
    • Economic Development
    • Gaming
    • Investigations
    • Social Services
    • TRANSPORTATION
  • Opinion
    • CT Viewpoints
    • CT Artpoints
DONATE
Reflecting Connecticut’s Reality.
    COVID-19
    Vaccine Info
    Money
    Politics
    Education
    Health
    Justice
    More
    Environment
    Economic Development
    Gaming
    Investigations
    Social Services
    TRANSPORTATION
    Opinion
    CT Viewpoints
    CT Artpoints

LET�S GET SOCIAL

Show your love for great stories and out standing journalism

Justice Dept. sues to block Aetna-Humana, Anthem-Cigna mergers

  • Health
  • by Ana Radelat
  • July 21, 2016
  • View as "Clean Read" "Exit Clean Read"
U.S. Attorney General Loretta Lynch announces antitrust lawsuits against mergers involving two Hartford insurers.

U.S. Department of Justice video

U.S. Attorney General Loretta Lynch announces antitrust lawsuits against mergers involving two Hartford insurers.

Updated at 6:45 p.m.

Washington – The Justice Department filed lawsuits Thursday to block proposed mergers between Aetna and Humana and Anthem and Cigna, and the insurers said they will fight back.

“If allowed to proceed, the mergers would fundamentally reshape the health care industry,” said U.S. Attorney General Loretta Lynch.

Justice Department officials derided one of the reasons the insurers cited in arguing for approval of the mergers – that it would result in efficiencies that would boost revenues and profits.

Deputy Associate Attorney General Bill Baer called the insurers’ proposals to divest themselves of “small pieces” of their companies to allay the DOJ’s concerns about the mergers’ impact on competition in the market “incomplete and totally inadequate.”

Connecticut had approved the Aetna-Humana merger, but not acted on the Anthem-Cigna deal yet. On Thursday, the Connecticut Insurance Department said it would halt its review of the deal.

“As a result of the federal antitrust lawsuit, the Connecticut Insurance Department has immediately suspended its review of Anthem’s Form A application,” said Connecticut Insurance Department spokeswoman Donna Tommelleo.

Connecticut Insurance Commissioner Katharine Wade has come under fire – and been the subject of calls for her recusal – for her role in the review of the Anthem-Cigna merger. Wade is the leading state regulator of the deal, but also a former Cigna employee whose husband still works for the company.

In a joint statement, Aetna and Humana said they plan to “vigorously defend” their pending merger in response to the Justice Department lawsuit.”

“A combined company is in the best interest of consumers, particularly seniors seeking affordable, high-quality Medicare Advantage (MA) plans,” the insurers’ statement said.

But the Justice Department said it was seeking to block the merger to preserve competition in the Medicare Advantage market.

“Since they began their negotiations, Aetna and Humana knew that their
competition against each other in Medicare Advantage was an antitrust problem,” the DOJ lawsuit said. “In nearly 90 percent of the counties where Aetna offers Medicare Advantage, it competes directly with Humana.”

The lawsuit also said, “Aetna’s proposed $37 billion merger with Humana would lead to higher health insurance prices, reduced benefits, less innovation, and worse service for over a million Americans.”

In a letter distributed to employees Thursday, a defiant Mark Bertolini, Aetna’s chairman and CEO, said the company would continue to pursue its marriage with Humana despite the Justice Department’s suit.

“We look forward to sharing the facts in court, and we will continue to press forward,” Bertolini wrote. “In the meantime, our integration planning continues. I would like to thank all those who continue working to close the deal and plan for a successful combination of our companies.”

Bertolini also said he would be hosting a town hall with employees Monday.

The Justice Department’s Antitrust Division cited other concerns in moving to block the proposed $54 billion merger between Anthem and Cigna.

“It would combine two of the few remaining commercial health-insurance options for businesses and individuals in markets throughout the country. And in doing so, it would substantially lessen competition, harming millions of American consumers, as well as doctors and hospitals,” the lawsuit said.

The lawsuit also said, “Anthem has also earned a reputation in many markets for having poor customer service, being slow to innovate, and being difficult to work with for doctors and hospitals. The president of Anthem’s Indiana business conceded, ‘There are some customers, some prospects who loathe us.’”

Anthem also said it will challenge the DOJ lawsuit, “but will remain receptive to any efforts to reach a settlement with DOJ that would allow us to complete the transaction and deliver its benefits at a critical time when American consumers are seeking high quality healthcare services with greater value at less cost.”

The DOJ also said the mergers would hurt competition in the state health insurance exchanges established under the Affordable Care Act.

Connecticut is one of 11 states that joined the DOJ’s lawsuit against the Anthem-Cigna merger plans, but the state did not join eight states that joined the suit to block the Aetna-Humana deal.

Cigna headquarters in Bloomfield

Cigna Corp.

Cigna headquarters in Bloomfield

“We are asking the court today to find this merger in violation of antitrust law and to permanently enjoin it from taking place,” said Connecticut Attorney George Jepsen, “Both Anthem and Cigna have a significant presence in Connecticut’s healthcare market. According to our analysis, all five of Connecticut’s metropolitan markets would be among the 35 markets nationwide that would be negatively impacted by this merger.”

The state’s complaint said the merger would hurt competition in the state in the large group market and plans sold to individuals through public exchanges, “leaving employers and individual consumers vulnerable to increased costs and providers subject to decreased rates, with few, if any, options to find better alternatives.

“Additionally, the merger would remove Cigna, which has been an innovative leader in the industry’s move to value-based care, as a competitive force in Connecticut’s market,” Jepsen said.

Costly breakup

The DOJ lawsuit said Aetna agreed to pay Humana a $1 billion “break-up fee” if the merger were not consumated by Dec. 31, 2016.

“From the outset, Aetna and Humana realized that their deal raised significant
antitrust issues. To convince Humana to proceed in the face of antitrust risks, Aetna…sought to downplay the antitrust issues it knew this deal would raise.”

“When preparing a presentation for the company’s board of directors, senior Aetna executives circulated a list of ‘words to avoid,’ which included terms likely to raise law enforcement concerns, such as ‘markets,’ ‘dominate/dominance,’ and ‘consolidate,’ ” the lawsuit said. “But merely avoiding those words does not make the merger any less likely to harm consumers by eliminating competition.”

The breakup fee Anthem must pay Cigna if the merger is not completed is about $1.8 billion. The DOJ said Anthem and Cigna were also “well aware of the competitive problems the deal would create.”

“In October 2014, Cigna’s chief financial officer warned the CEO to stop using words like ‘dominant’ and ‘market share’ when analyzing the potential deal because they are ‘both sensitive words from a post deal review perspective,'” the DOJ lawsuit said.

Clare Krusing, spokeswoman for America’s Health Insurance Plans, an association that represents the nation’s health insurers, said the DOJ’s action Thursday is not the end of the companies’ efforts to merge.

“Today’s announcement is a step in an ongoing process,” she said. “Mergers among health plans can deliver significant benefits by combining complimentary areas of expertise to ensure consumers get the best value for their health care dollars. Notably, many insurance departments across the country have approved these mergers.”

Aetna headquarters in Hartford

Aetna

Aetna headquarters in Hartford

Meanwhile, members of a coalition of medical associations and consumer organizations that opposed the mergers hailed the Justice Department’s actions.

“This is an important first step in highlighting the significant deficiencies in these proposed mergers, and their negative impact on patient access to care in Connecticut and throughout the country,” said Matthew Katz, chief executive officer at the Connecticut Medical Society.

Katz said Connecticut doctors had “expressed major concerns with giant health insurers becoming goliaths with exclusive or near-exclusive power to dictate price and care delivery to the detriment of patient medical care.”

The American Medical Association said, “The prospect of reducing five national health insurance carriers to just three is unacceptable. Given the mergers’ potential to significantly compromise market competition, the AMA strongly supports the antitrust challenge from federal regulators.”

Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., who urged the Justice Department to block the merger last month in a letter that was also signed by six other senators, said, “This federal court action thankfully should stop misguided mega-mergers that would kill jobs and raise prices.”

“Such mammoth mergers threaten jobs, hike prices, lessen choice, and lower health care quality. I will continue working to help these companies be successful, thriving, independent competitors here in Connecticut,” Blumenthal said.

Sign up for CT Mirror's free daily news summary.

Free to Read. Not Free to Produce.

The Connecticut Mirror is a nonprofit newsroom. 90% of our revenue comes from people like you. If you value our reporting please consider making a donation. You'll enjoy reading CT Mirror even more knowing you helped make it happen.

YES, I'LL DONATE TODAY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ana Radelat Ana has written about politics and policy in Washington, D.C.. for Gannett, Thompson Reuters and UPI. She was a special correspondent for the Miami Herald, and a regular contributor to The New York TImes, Advertising Age and several other publications. She has also worked in broadcast journalism, for CNN and several local NPR stations. She is a graduate of the University of Maryland School of Journalism.

SEE WHAT READERS SAID

RELATED STORIES
Lamont edges close to deal on sports betting. Just don’t ask for odds.
by Mark Pazniokas

Connecticut is close to a deal with the tribes over rights to sports betting.

As seniors complain of trouble scheduling COVID vaccines, Connecticut beefs up its appointment phone line
by Jenna Carlesso

Gov. Lamont praised Connecticut's efforts to vaccinate seniors but wasn't as eager to discuss problems with the state's appointment system.

The state’s largest COVID vaccine center is up and running — but so far, there’s no formal plan to pay for it
by Jenna Carlesso and Dave Altimari

State officials say the vaccine rollout is similar to the mass testing plans and hunt for protective equipment last spring.

Pandemic eases, and complicates, legislating
by Mark Pazniokas

The legislature’s Labor and Public Employees Committee co-chairs skipped the masks, but they were very socially distant.

Health issues carried weight on the campaign trail.
by Victoria Knight | Kaiser Health News

Even with the Democrats’ newfound Senate majority, differences in health policy between the party’s moderate and progressive wings will persist.

Support Our Work

Show your love for great stories and outstanding journalism.

$
Select One
  • Monthly
  • Yearly
  • Once
Artpoint painter
CT ViewpointsCT Artpoints
Opinion It’s time to standardize arts grants in Connecticut
by Mandi Jackson and Daniel Fitzmaurice

What all arts organizations need most right now is multi-year, unrestricted general operating support with simplified, fair processes for accountability. This would allow the arts community to better respond to the needs of Connecticut residents instead of the political process, lobbyists, or wealthy donors.

Opinion Accessory dwelling units are a good thing
by Toni Gold

Connecticut’s large, old houses are a resource that any town should treasure — not just for their charm and historical value, but because of their potential for adaptation. One tool that can help ensure the viability of these structures is zoning, and particularly zoning for accessory dwelling units (ADUs). There’s a movement to  legalize ADUs statewide. It’s a good idea whose time has come.

Opinion New Haven and Yale: Giamatti and DiLieto:  A historic moment? Or a model? 
by Neil Thomas Proto

The City of New Haven’s effort today to seek an increase in financial contribution from Yale is more historically justified than is often recognized.

Opinion A call to save arms: is vaccination really the solution?
by Genevieve Diamant

Economic modelling done by professional statisticians is often used to claim that the ounce of prevention provided by a vaccine is much better than the pound of cure that well-funded hospitals, fully staffed with professional nurses and doctors, using effective pharmaceutical remedies, can provide. But is this actually true?

Artwork Grand guidance
by Anne:Gogh

In a world of systemic oppression aimed towards those of darker skintones – representation matters. We are more than our equity elusive environments, more than numbers in a prison and much more than victims of societal dispositions. This piece depicts a melanated young man draped in a cape ascending high above multiple forms of oppression. […]

Artwork Shea
by Anthony Valentine

Shea is a story about race and social inequalities that plague America. It is a narrative that prompts the question, “Do you know what it’s like to wake up in new skin?”

Artwork The Declaration of Human Rights
by Andres Chaparro

Through my artwork I strive to create an example of ideas that reflect my desire to raise social consciousness, and cultural awareness. Jazz music is the catalyst to all my work, and plays a major influence in each piece of work.”

Artwork ‘A thing of beauty. Destroy it forever’
by Richard DiCarlo | Derby

During times like these it’s often fun to revisit something familiar and approach things with a different slant. I have been taking some Pop culture and Art masterpieces and applying the vintage 1960’s and 70’s classic figures (Fisher Price, little people) to the make an amusing pieces. Here is my homage to Fisher -Price, Yellow […]

Twitter Feed
A Twitter List by CTMirror

Engage

  • Reflections Tickets & Sponsorships
  • Events
  • Donate
  • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Submit to Viewpoints
  • Submit to ArtPoints
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Commenting Guidelines
  • Legal Notices
  • Contact Us

About

  • About CT Mirror
  • Announcements
  • Board
  • Staff
  • Sponsors and Funders
  • Donors
  • Friends of CT Mirror
  • History
  • Financial
  • Policies
  • Strategic Plan

Opportunity

  • Advertising and Sponsorship
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Use of Photography
  • Work for Us

Go Deeper

  • Steady Habits Podcast
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Five Things

The Connecticut News Project, Inc. 1049 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06105. Phone: 860-218-6380

© Copyright 2021, The Connecticut News Project. All Rights Reserved. Website by Web Publisher PRO