Free Daily Headlines :

  • COVID-19
  • Vaccine Info
  • Money
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Health
  • Justice
  • More
    • Environment
    • Economic Development
    • Gaming
    • Investigations
    • Social Services
    • TRANSPORTATION
  • Opinion
    • CT Viewpoints
    • CT Artpoints
DONATE
Reflecting Connecticut’s Reality.
    COVID-19
    Vaccine Info
    Money
    Politics
    Education
    Health
    Justice
    More
    Environment
    Economic Development
    Gaming
    Investigations
    Social Services
    TRANSPORTATION
    Opinion
    CT Viewpoints
    CT Artpoints

LET�S GET SOCIAL

Show your love for great stories and out standing journalism

Supreme Court sharply divided over individual mandate

  • Health
  • by Ana Radelat
  • March 27, 2012
  • View as "Clean Read" "Exit Clean Read"

Washington — On the second day of oral arguments over the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act, a divided Supreme Court turned its attention to whether Congress had the authority to require most Americans to have health insurance.

At the center of the health care bill, the individual mandate helped persuade health insurers, including Connecticut-based companies like Aetna and Cigna, to accept other reforms on the way they do business.

The individual mandate would go into effect in 2014 if the Supreme Court does not reject it. By threatening those who don’t buy insurance with a penalty, the mandate would bring millions of uninsured into the insurance market.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act also provides subsidies to help low-income Americans purchase health coverage.

Many of those newly insured Americans would be young and healthy, making it easier for insurers to meet another health care law reform — the requirement that they offer coverage to all Americans, even those with pre-existing health conditions.

But attorneys for the National Federation of Independent Business and the 26 states that challenged the health care act argued that Congress overreached in mandating insurance coverage.

Michael A. Carvin, an attorney who argued the case for the independent business federation, said Congress “is forcing people for paternalistic reasons,” to buy insurance, exceeding its power.

Conservative Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito were sympathetic to that argument.

“If the government can do that, what else can it do?” Scalia asked.

Could Congress could also require individuals to buy broccoli or gym memberships to force Americans to lead healthier livestyles? Scalia asked.

But the liberal members of the court, Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Elena Kagan seemed to agree with Solicitor General Donald Verrilli Jr.

Verrilli argued that Congress has the authority to impose an individual mandate under the Constitution’s Commerce Clause, which governs interstate commerce.

Some justices said there should be a fix for the cost shifting that occurs under the current health care system. With 40 million Americans uninsured — nearly 400,000 of them in Connecticut — many patients leave huge medical bill unpaid.

That forces hospitals and doctors to raise the cost of medicine and health insurers to raise premiums.

“The people who don’t participate in the market make it more difficult for people who do,” Ginsburg said.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Anthony Kennedy, who could be decisive swing votes, were harder to read.

At one point Roberts also wondered that if Congress forced people to buy insurance, “What is next?”

But he disagreed with attorneys arguing against the law that there are those who don’t need health care coverage so Congress should not invoke the Commerce Clause.

“Everyone is in this market,” Roberts said.

Rep. Chris Murphy, D-5th District, who is seeking the Democratic nomination for U.S. Senate, said if the Supreme Court overturns the health care act, “it would be a purely political decision.”

“It would be a radical rewrite of the Commerce Clause to suggest Congress does not have the authority to regulate health care,” he said.

The American Health Insurance Plans, a Washington-based trade association representing the nation’s health insurers, has asked the Supreme Court to toss out other reforms if they rule the individual mandate unconstitutional.

“Eight states enacted various (reforms) in the 1990s without covering everyone, and these reforms resulted in a rise in insurance premiums, a reduction of individual insurance enrollment and no significant decrease in the number of uninsured,” AHIP President Karen Ignagni said.

On Wednesday Verrilli will ask the Supreme Court to sever some of the ACA’s reforms if the court throws out the mandate.

Mickey Herbert, former CEO of ConnectiCare, said it’s “pretty critical” for the insurance industry to have the individual mandate remain part of the law.

Without a mandate, there are still ways to encourage people to buy coverage, he said. Those include strongly encouraging people to sign up when they get their driver’s licenses renewed, automatically enrolling people and letting them opt out, or requiring that people who don’t get coverage when they’re first eligible pay higher premiums if they sign up later — something Medicare does.

Herbert also said that nothing would prevent Connecticut from imposing its own individual mandate, as Massachusetts did, if the federal law is struck down. But the loss of federal funding for people to buy insurance could make expanding coverage in Connecticut far more difficult, he said.

Others, however, don’t see the individual mandate as critical to health reform.

Ellen Andrews, executive director of the Connecticut Health Policy Project, said that even with a mandate, there will have to be efforts to ensure that everyone enrolls in an insurance plan. She noted that not everyone who qualifies for Medicaid in Connecticut, which people can get for free, sign up, and that any coverage expansion, mandated or not, will require a major marketing effort.

Some portions of the health reform law have already been implemented and could go forward without the mandate, said state Healthcare Advocate Victoria Veltri.

They include a limit on the amount of money insurers can spend on costs unrelated to medical care or quality improvement, and the elimination of lifetime benefit limits in insurance plans.

But she said losing the mandate would make other key provisions difficult.

“We would have to come up with some very creative ways to entice people into coverage,” she said.

But state Sen. Andrew Roraback, a Goshen Republican who is running for Congress, said he thinks the law is unconstitutional, and that if the mandate is struck down, the rest of the law will not stand. In that case, the law wouldn’t achieve its goal of covering nearly all Americans, and the government wouldn’t get the revenue from penalties paid by people who don’t get insurance.

“When those two things are stripped away, the program becomes a two-legged stool,” he said.

Jeannette DeJesús, special adviser to the governor for health reform, called the individual mandate “the linchpin” of the health law. If the court were to deem the law unconstitutional, she said, the effect on Connecticut would depend whether the ruling struck down the entire law, including subsidies to buy coverage, or more narrowly prohibited the mandate, which would be challenging to insurers but could allow other reforms to take place.

If the whole law were struck down?

“There’s no doubt that we would continue in our efforts to reform health systems here in the state, but we would return to a more incremental approach,” she said. “We really need large-scale sweeping transformations in order to address this more effectively for folks. It would be a setback, but we will have to find a way to move forward.”

The Supreme Court is expected to issue a decision on the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act in June.

Sign up for CT Mirror's free daily news summary.

Free to Read. Not Free to Produce.

The Connecticut Mirror is a nonprofit newsroom. 90% of our revenue comes from people like you. If you value our reporting please consider making a donation. You'll enjoy reading CT Mirror even more knowing you helped make it happen.

YES, I'LL DONATE TODAY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ana Radelat

SEE WHAT READERS SAID

RELATED STORIES
Health issues carried weight on the campaign trail.
by Victoria Knight | Kaiser Health News

Even with the Democrats’ newfound Senate majority, differences in health policy between the party’s moderate and progressive wings will persist.

Trump’s pardons included health care execs behind massive fraud
by Fred Schulte | Kaiser Health News

At the last minute, President Donald Trump granted pardons to several individuals convicted in huge Medicare swindles that prosecutors alleged often harmed or endangered elderly and infirm patients while fleecing taxpayers. “These aren’t just technical financial crimes. These were major, major crimes,” said Louis Saccoccio, chief executive officer of the National Health Care Anti-Fraud Association, […]

‘It’s a nightmare:’ A growing number of seniors are unable to book vaccine appointments as problems mount
by Dave Altimari and Jenna Carlesso

The state acknowledged Friday in an email to local health workers that some residents are waiting days for a callback.

The game is changing. Chris Murphy says he’s ready to play.
by Mark Pazniokas

The question for Sen. Chris Murphy no longer is where might he go next, but what can he do now.

More than 300 teachers vaccinated at Southbury clinic; State says older residents should come first
by Dave Altimari

Some teachers are getting vaccinated while the state is trying to get the COVID-19 vaccine out to older residents first.

Support Our Work

Show your love for great stories and outstanding journalism.

$
Select One
  • Monthly
  • Yearly
  • Once
Artpoint painter
CT ViewpointsCT Artpoints
Opinion Miguel Cardona, who are you?
by Ann Policelli Cronin

When I ask Connecticut teachers about Miguel Cardona, those who know him or have worked with him say that he is really nice guy who knows what the challenges in our classrooms are, knows how to help teachers to improve their teaching, and respects public schools. All good. But what is his vision for teaching and learning that he will bring to the U.S. Department of Education?

Opinion Connecticut needs a strong two-party system, this Democrat says
by Edward Marcus

J.R. Romano’s recent resignation as the state’s Republican Party chair has brought into focus the need for a viable opposition party in Connecticut. It is not healthy politics when everything is totally controlled by one party:  the legislature, the governorship, and most of the major municipalities in our state.

Opinion Connecticut’s $100 million college shell game
by Stephen Adair

The plan to consolidate the 12 community colleges in Connecticut into one college with 12 campuses is called “Students First,” which is ironic because it does not fund students first.  It funds a new administration in a new, statewide bureaucracy. The Board of Regents (BOR) and the Connecticut State Colleges and Universities (CSCU) system office […]

Opinion Inconsistent television captioning is a barrier to equal access
by Jeffrey Bravin and Barbara Cassin

Our world long ago entered the age of the 24-hour news cycle, and a full understanding of the “who, what, when, where and why” of the news is critical for deaf, deafblind and hard of hearing citizens. Yet, Connecticut’s inconsistent quality of television captioning locks our community out of the complete sense of what is happening.

Artwork Grand guidance
by Anne:Gogh

In a world of systemic oppression aimed towards those of darker skintones – representation matters. We are more than our equity elusive environments, more than numbers in a prison and much more than victims of societal dispositions. This piece depicts a melanated young man draped in a cape ascending high above multiple forms of oppression. […]

Artwork Shea
by Anthony Valentine

Shea is a story about race and social inequalities that plague America. It is a narrative that prompts the question, “Do you know what it’s like to wake up in new skin?”

Artwork The Declaration of Human Rights
by Andres Chaparro

Through my artwork I strive to create an example of ideas that reflect my desire to raise social consciousness, and cultural awareness. Jazz music is the catalyst to all my work, and plays a major influence in each piece of work.”

Artwork ‘A thing of beauty. Destroy it forever’
by Richard DiCarlo | Derby

During times like these it’s often fun to revisit something familiar and approach things with a different slant. I have been taking some Pop culture and Art masterpieces and applying the vintage 1960’s and 70’s classic figures (Fisher Price, little people) to the make an amusing pieces. Here is my homage to Fisher -Price, Yellow […]

Twitter Feed
A Twitter List by CTMirror

Engage

  • Reflections Tickets & Sponsorships
  • Events
  • Donate
  • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Submit to Viewpoints
  • Submit to ArtPoints
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Commenting Guidelines
  • Legal Notices
  • Contact Us

About

  • About CT Mirror
  • Announcements
  • Board
  • Staff
  • Sponsors and Funders
  • Donors
  • Friends of CT Mirror
  • History
  • Financial
  • Policies
  • Strategic Plan

Opportunity

  • Advertising and Sponsorship
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Use of Photography
  • Work for Us

Go Deeper

  • Steady Habits Podcast
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Five Things

The Connecticut News Project, Inc. 1049 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06105. Phone: 860-218-6380

© Copyright 2021, The Connecticut News Project. All Rights Reserved. Website by Web Publisher PRO