Testing nursing home staff is costly and uncertain. Here’s why
As coronavirus cases continue to surge nationally, more questions have been raised about Gov. Ned Lamont’s decision to modify testing requirements at nursing homes. And now, three legal aid organizations have signed onto a letter expressing concern on behalf of nursing home residents, arguing Lamont’s decision could lead to more nursing home infections and deaths.
In June, Lamont issued an executive order requiring weekly testing for nursing home staff. But a few days later, the governor scaled that back, saying testing staff wasn’t necessary if the facility was COVID-free for two weeks.
In a joint letter to Lamont, three legal aid groups say that modification is out of step with federal guidance from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which recommends testing all nursing home staff, and says weekly testing for asymptomatic workers without known exposures should continue unless there is “minimal-to-no community transmission.”
“We don’t want to see what happened to nursing home residents be repeated,” said Kevin Brophy, an elder law attorney with Connecticut Legal Services, one of the groups signing onto the letter.
Brophy said the change has his clients — nursing home residents and their families — scared.
“What we’re concerned about is that you have staff that don’t live in the nursing home. They work in the community, and they could, unintentionally, bring COVID-19 into the nursing home,” Brophy said.
Infection rates at nursing homes have dropped significantly. But more than 2,700 nursing home residents have died from COVID-19 complications, according to state statistics, which accounts for more than 60% of the state’s total death toll.
Understanding the ‘toughest’ testing standards for nursing home workers
During a media briefing on July 9, Lamont said he believes Connecticut has “the toughest testing standards at nursing homes, probably in the country.”
But in fact, neighboring states have handled the issue of testing nursing home staff more aggressively.
In New York, where more than 6,000 nursing home residents died from the virus, Gov. Andrew Cuomo adopted stricter requirements.
“Nursing homes and adult care facilities located in regions that have entered Phase 2 of reopening (at this point, that is every region of New York State), must test or arrange testing for staff once a week,” said Jill Montag, a spokesperson for the New York State Department of Public Health, in an email.
In Massachusetts, state officials are requiring nursing homes conduct new baseline testing of nursing home staff no later than July 19.
After that, weekly or bi-weekly testing is required at varying degrees of intensity, even if a facility is virus-free, said Ann Scales, a spokesperson with the Massachusetts Department of Public Health in an email.
Sara Parker McKernan, a legislative and policy advocate with New Haven Legal Assistance, which signed onto the letter questioning Lamont’s order, said the CDC is specifically calling for weekly testing for asymptomatic workers.
Lamont’s order says weekly testing must resume if a resident or worker at a “COVID-free” facility is identified as having “a new case of nursing home facility-onset COVID-19.”
But McKernan said any pause in testing is wrong.
“The CDC specifically calls for weekly testing with the provision that ‘state and local officials may adjust the recommendation for weekly viral testing of [workers] based on the prevalence of the virus in their community,’” McKernan said in an email.
Deidre Gifford, acting commissioner of the state Department of Public Health, said Lamont’s modification was in line with CDC guidance.
When asked about the change Thursday, she said it wasn’t a loosening of testing standards. And she rejected any assertions that the change was based on testing cost.
“We didn’t relax the standards. We just clarified,” Gifford said. “It wasn’t a decision based on cost. It was a decision based on coming into alignment with the federal guidance.”
Who pays the ‘extraordinary’ cost of testing nursing home staff?
Right now, a combination of state and federal dollars are paying to test staff at nursing homes around Connecticut, according to the state Department of Public Health.
But that money runs out at the end of August.
Beyond that, who pays is an unknown.
“The federal government has been unclear regarding its commitments to paying for testing, an issue our state and many other states are facing,” said Av Harris, a spokesperson for the state Department of Public Health, in an email.
“This isn’t a Connecticut issue, this is a national issue,” said Mag Morelli, president of LeadingAge Connecticut, which represents not-for-profit aging service providers, including nursing homes in the state. “We’re really looking for some funding on the national level to be able to provide the testing that’s needed,” Morelli said.
In the past two weeks, at least 20,000 nursing home staff have been tested via Lamont’s executive order, according to Lita Orefice, senior advisor to the commissioner of the Department of Public Health.
So what are those tests — and their associated materials, time, and sample work — costing?
Right now, the state refuses to release exact pricing information on how much it is paying at least seven vendors to process samples collected from nursing home staff across Connecticut.
But it has disclosed an average for each test and its associated lab work.
That price tag is $117, which means the total cost of running those 20,000 tests for nursing home staff was more than $2 million.
“The cost of weekly testing can be extraordinary,” said Matthew Barrett, president and CEO of the Connecticut Association of Health Care Facilities.
“Those would be … unsustainable costs to expect nursing homes to bear,” Barrett said. “Especially … coming off of, and … not really being on the other side of, the COVID-19 pandemic in Connecticut.”
Jesse Martin, with SEIU 1199 New England — a union representing workers at around 70 nursing homes in Connecticut — said he thinks Lamont modified his executive order because of the price of running those COVID-19 tests.
“We think it is cost,” Martin said. “Right now the state is only set to pay for nursing home staff testing through the end of August … it is going to be a fiscal cliff that many nursing homes are going to face come September 1.”
Morelli said throughout the ever-evolving pandemic staff have continued to show up to work, caring for residents despite having to navigate guidelines that seem to be forever in flux.
And that’s part of what makes mapping out any certain future for COVID-19 testing in Connecticut so difficult, she said. Everything is changing.
“I don’t look at it as the door being shut on [Aug. 31],” Morelli said. “But we really, really need to have the federal government step in and help us out. Help the state out and help us out with this cost.”
Connecticut Public Radio’s Frankie Graziano contributed to this story.
Sign up for CT Mirror's free daily news summary.
Free to Read. Not Free to Produce.
The Connecticut Mirror is a nonprofit newsroom. 90% of our revenue comes from people like you. If you value our reporting please consider making a donation. You'll enjoy reading CT Mirror even more knowing you helped make it happen.YES, I'LL DONATE TODAY