Free Daily Headlines :

  • COVID-19
  • Vaccine Info
  • Money
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Health
  • Justice
  • More
    • Environment
    • Economic Development
    • Gaming
    • Investigations
    • Social Services
    • TRANSPORTATION
  • Opinion
    • CT Viewpoints
    • CT Artpoints
DONATE
Reflecting Connecticut’s Reality.
    COVID-19
    Vaccine Info
    Money
    Politics
    Education
    Health
    Justice
    More
    Environment
    Economic Development
    Gaming
    Investigations
    Social Services
    TRANSPORTATION
    Opinion
    CT Viewpoints
    CT Artpoints

LET�S GET SOCIAL

Show your love for great stories and out standing journalism

Cigna, Anthem, await multi-billion-dollar decision after bitter court fight

  • Justice
  • by Ana Radelat
  • March 14, 2019
  • View as "Clean Read" "Exit Clean Read"

Cigna Corp.

Cigna headquarters in Bloomfield

Cigna and Anthem have battled for nearly two years, each seeking billions of dollars in damages in a bitter breakup after a failed merger. Now a chancery court judge in Delaware is about to decide who walks away with the money.

That decision by Delaware Chancery Court Judge Travis Laster is expected to roil the industry and could have a huge impact on Bloomfield-based Cigna, which could either receive a windfall as large as $16 billion or be required to pay Anthem, based in Indianapolis, Ind. as much as $20 billion.

Laster has authority to decide who wins the case, and how much the loser must pay.

Anthem, with about 40.2 million customers, is the nation’s second-largest health insurer, behind United Healthcare. Cigna is the fourth-largest, with about 16 million customers.

Larry Hamermesh, executive director of the University of Pennsylvania’s Institute for Law and Economics and an expert in Delaware corporate law, said each insurer is large enough to be able to handle whatever Laster decides it should pay.

“I imagine they could handle it, but it will be more than the change in the till,” Hamermesh said.

That is unless Laster decides that neither Cigna or Anthem deserve anything.

“He could say ‘a pox on both your houses,’ which wouldn’t surprise me in this case where both sides are shooting for the moon,” Hamermesh said.

The court proceedings peeled back the curtain on the disintegrating relationship between the insurers during the nearly two-year effort to merge. What began as a mutually agreed-upon merger morphed in such a way that it looked more like a hostile takeover.

Cigna and Anthem, a Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association licensee in 14 states, decided to merge in 2015. But the Justice Department opposed the merger, saying the marriage would restrict competition and result in higher premiums and poorer heath care. A federal appeals court agreed, with Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, then a judge serving in that court, the only dissenter.

The merger agreement included a $1.85 billion “breakup” fee, payable to Cigna, if the ill-fated $54 billion deal collapsed. But in the bitter aftermath of the courts’ decisions, Cigna decided it deserved more — a lot more.

In early 2017,  Cigna sued in the Delaware chancery court, arguing it is owed more than $16 billion as the injured party. Anthem countered it is owed $20 billion because Cigna sabotaged the deal.

The two-week trial based on the competing claims ended last week.

‘Cut us off at the knees’

During court testimony, Anthem lawyers alleged Cigna CEO David Cordani privately expressed regrets about agreeing to merge with Anthem, despite publicly backing the deal because it would be good for the company’s shareholders.

At the time of signing their deal, Anthem agreed to pay Cigna’s shareholders a premium of 38.4 percent, or $13.4 billion.

The deal also called for then-Anthem CEO Joseph Swedish to claim the top spot in the merged companies.

Anthem lawyers argued in court that Cordani wanted to remain in charge of Cigna and he, senior management and board members at Cigna decided to sabotage the merger to keep their jobs and capture the $1.85 billion breakup fee.

Cigna “cut us off at the knees,” Anthem Attorney Thomas Zielinski told Laster.

Glenn Kurtz, another Anthem lawyer, said Cigna hired lawyers and consultants to poke holes in the merger, something Anthem was unaware of.

Swedish testified that his company was “truly at war” with Cigna ‘s top brass in 2016 as he fought the Justice Department to keep the merger alive.

“He could say ‘a pox on both your houses,’ which wouldn’t surprise me in this case where both sides are shooting for the moon.”

Larry Hamermesh
Executive Director, University of Pennsylvania’s Institute for Law and Economics

Meanwhile, Cigna attorneys argued in court that Anthem never intended to fulfill its promises in the merger agreement. They said Anthem wanted to avoid fines for violating Blue Cross/Blue Shield guidelines with a “bias to Blue” strategy that would steal Cigna’s customers.  In the guise of promoting the merger, Anthem sought to undermine Cigna’s business by stealing confidential information and harassing its customers, Cigna claimed.

“Rather than promoting consumer choice and fostering the Cigna brand as a competitor to the Blues, Anthem would seek to herd Cigna customers under the Blue umbrella,” Cigna said in its court filing.

Anthem declined comment for this story. But Cigna said it was optimistic it would win the court battle.

“Cigna entered into a proposed merger deal with Anthem with a clear focus on enhancing customer value,” said Cigna spokesman Brian Henry. “Two federal courts and the Department of Justice evaluated the proposed deal, and ultimately chose to block it.  We are confident in the judicial process and strongly believe in our case.”

Ted Frech, an economics professor at the University of California, Santa Barbara, said it is rare for Cigna and Anthem to air so much corporate dirty laundry in open court.

“That was a real drawback,” Frech said. “It would have been so much better to have settled or not have revealed so much.”

Hamermesh, of the University of Pennsylvania, said “there’s obviously a lot of incentive to settle the case, but the sheer magnitude of the claims makes it harder to settle.”

Hamermesh also said there were “a lot of personalities” and “a lot of baggage” in the messy insurer breakup that makes the case hard to settle, even though there still may be time to come to an accord.

Laster has 90 days to issue a written opinion – but he could come to a decision earlier than that.

Sign up for CT Mirror's free daily news summary.

Free to Read. Not Free to Produce.

The Connecticut Mirror is a nonprofit newsroom. 90% of our revenue comes from people like you. If you value our reporting please consider making a donation. You'll enjoy reading CT Mirror even more knowing you helped make it happen.

YES, I'LL DONATE TODAY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ana Radelat Ana has written about politics and policy in Washington, D.C.. for Gannett, Thompson Reuters and UPI. She was a special correspondent for the Miami Herald, and a regular contributor to The New York TImes, Advertising Age and several other publications. She has also worked in broadcast journalism, for CNN and several local NPR stations. She is a graduate of the University of Maryland School of Journalism.

SEE WHAT READERS SAID

RELATED STORIES
What we’ve lost, what we’ve learned during our year of COVID
by CT Mirror Staff

On March 6, 2020, Gov. Ned Lamont announced that the first case of COVID-19 had been detected in Connecticut, and within weeks, life as we knew it was a memory. Schools were shut down, universities emptied, businesses shuttered. Those of us who were fortunate enough to be able to work from home set up shop at our […]

Plan to expand child tax credit offers hope along with direct payments
by Lisa Backus | C-HIT.ORG

When her car started making a noise more than a year ago, Chinara Johnson parked the vehicle and hasn’t used it since. As a New Haven mother of 5-year-old twin boys, one of whom is on the autism spectrum, and an 8-year-old daughter, Johnson doesn’t have the money to get the car running properly again. […]

Aid-in-dying bill clears key hurdle with committee passage
by Jenna Carlesso

The bill would let terminally ill patients access medication to end their lives.

Few tenants facing eviction have an attorney. Top lawmakers are poised to change that.
by Jacqueline Rabe Thomas

Legislation that would provide tenants facing eviction the "right to counsel" is a top priority for legislative leaders.

With billions in federal relief on the way to CT, legislators assert their role in deciding how to spend it
by Keith M. Phaneuf and Mark Pazniokas

With an unusual bill, state legislators are reminding Gov. Ned Lamont they have significant role in disbursing federal coronavirus relief.

Support Our Work

Show your love for great stories and outstanding journalism.

$
Select One
  • Monthly
  • Yearly
  • Once
Artpoint painter
CT ViewpointsCT Artpoints
Opinion Assisted suicide lobby spreads falsehoods to promote systemic ableism
by Stephen Mendelsohn

Proponents of assisted suicide repeatedly spread falsehoods to promote their lethal and ableist agenda.  The February 8 op-ed, “Aid in dying is not assisted suicide” is no exception. Suicide is defined as the act of taking one’s life intentionally.  The person who intentionally ingests a prescribed lethal overdose more closely fits the dictionary definition of suicide than the despondent person who jumps off a bridge.  The desire for suicide is a cry for help, even when redefined as a “medical treatment option.”

Opinion TCI will create a fourth gasoline tax
by Christian A. Herb

The Transportation Climate Initiative, or TCI, calls for a proposed emissions fee on gasoline to help battle climate change. On the surface, supporters say it is a small price to pay to help save the planet; and if you truly believe that this is the case, then you should consider voting for it. Despite the administration’s efforts to go out of their way to not call TCI a tax, the simple truth is that it will only create additional financial hardships on lower- and middle-income families struggling to make ends meet during the pandemic.

Opinion Let’s keep telehealth when the pandemic ends
by Steven Madonick, MD

Telehealth may lead to positive, even transformational changes in psychiatric care, and Connecticut needs to keep it after the pandemic. Connecticut needs to pass the necessary laws to continue telehealth and telephonic care.

Opinion The public health bill no one is talking about, but should be
by Brian Festa

On February 16,  the legislature's Public Health Committee conducted a public hearing on two bills, S.B. 568 and H.B. 6423, both of which would eliminate the religious exemption to mandatory vaccinations for Connecticut schoolchildren.  The hearing was capped at 24 hours, depriving nearly 1,500 members of the public who had registered for the hearing their opportunity to be heard.  The vast majority of those who did testify, and who submitted written testimony, opposed the bill.  The committee is expected to vote on the bill as early as  today. 

Artwork Grand guidance
by Anne:Gogh

In a world of systemic oppression aimed towards those of darker skintones – representation matters. We are more than our equity elusive environments, more than numbers in a prison and much more than victims of societal dispositions. This piece depicts a melanated young man draped in a cape ascending high above multiple forms of oppression. […]

Artwork Shea
by Anthony Valentine

Shea is a story about race and social inequalities that plague America. It is a narrative that prompts the question, “Do you know what it’s like to wake up in new skin?”

Artwork The Declaration of Human Rights
by Andres Chaparro

Through my artwork I strive to create an example of ideas that reflect my desire to raise social consciousness, and cultural awareness. Jazz music is the catalyst to all my work, and plays a major influence in each piece of work.”

Artwork ‘A thing of beauty. Destroy it forever’
by Richard DiCarlo | Derby

During times like these it’s often fun to revisit something familiar and approach things with a different slant. I have been taking some Pop culture and Art masterpieces and applying the vintage 1960’s and 70’s classic figures (Fisher Price, little people) to the make an amusing pieces. Here is my homage to Fisher -Price, Yellow […]

Twitter Feed
A Twitter List by CTMirror

Engage

  • Reflections Tickets & Sponsorships
  • Events
  • Donate
  • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Submit to Viewpoints
  • Submit to ArtPoints
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Commenting Guidelines
  • Legal Notices
  • Contact Us

About

  • About CT Mirror
  • Announcements
  • Board
  • Staff
  • Sponsors and Funders
  • Donors
  • Friends of CT Mirror
  • History
  • Financial
  • Policies
  • Strategic Plan

Opportunity

  • Advertising and Sponsorship
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Use of Photography
  • Work for Us

Go Deeper

  • Steady Habits Podcast
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Five Things

The Connecticut News Project, Inc. 1049 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06105. Phone: 860-218-6380

© Copyright 2021, The Connecticut News Project. All Rights Reserved. Website by Web Publisher PRO