Free Daily Headlines :

  • COVID-19
  • Vaccine Info
  • Money
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Health
  • Justice
  • More
    • Environment
    • Economic Development
    • Gaming
    • Investigations
    • Social Services
    • TRANSPORTATION
  • Opinion
    • CT Viewpoints
    • CT Artpoints
DONATE
Reflecting Connecticut’s Reality.
    COVID-19
    Vaccine Info
    Money
    Politics
    Education
    Health
    Justice
    More
    Environment
    Economic Development
    Gaming
    Investigations
    Social Services
    TRANSPORTATION
    Opinion
    CT Viewpoints
    CT Artpoints

LET�S GET SOCIAL

Show your love for great stories and out standing journalism

CT Supreme Court releases opinion declaring Ned Lamont’s emergency powers constitutional

  • COVID-19
  • by Mark Pazniokas
  • March 29, 2021
  • View as "Clean Read" "Exit Clean Read"

file photo :: ctmirror.org

Andrew McDonald wrote for the unanimous majority.

The Connecticut Supreme Court issued a unanimous opinion Monday providing the legal rationale behind the terse order released on New Year’s Eve that upheld the constitutionality of Gov. Ned Lamont’s emergency powers during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The opinion upholds both the constitutionality of the state’s two emergency powers laws and the governor’s exercise of his authority under them, providing what could be the last word by the state’s highest court on the legal basis for an unprecedented series of executive orders.

Responding to an appeal by a Milford pub owner aggrieved by Lamont’s order closing bars, the court sidestepped whether the order was necessary, focusing instead on the statutory and constitutional authority behind all his orders during the pandemic.

“As long as Governor Lamont is acting within this admittedly broad statutory and constitutional authority — which we conclude that he is — it is not the job of this court to second-guess those policy decisions,” the court concluded.

The opinion was written by Justice Andrew J. McDonald, who has a unique perspective on the court as to the intersection of legislative and executive authority: He was a co-chair of the legislature’s Judiciary Committee and was Gov. Dannel P. Malloy’s general counsel.

McDonald relied on a broad range of political, legal and linguistic authorities to discern whether the legislature had properly empowered Lamont or if a pandemic met the legal and plain-language definitions of “catastrophe” and “major disaster.”

The liberal justice nodded to both Donald J. Trump and Chief Justice John Roberts of the U.S. Supreme Court, as well as Connecticut’s significant body of case law, as he addressed those disparate questions of law and language.

Lamont declared a state of emergency under a public health law, which specifies a procedure for a special legislative committee to block the governor, and a civil preparedness law. The latter has no clear method for legislative oversight, except for a man-made disaster. The court all but nudged the General Assembly to consider creating a broader oversight process.

“[W]e fail to see why the legislature chose not to include a provision for legislative oversight of a governor’s proclaimed civil preparedness emergency, other than for a man-made disaster,” the court wrote in a footnote. “Certainly, this could be addressed by the General Assembly in its current, or a future, legislative session, if the legislature deems it appropriate.”

The current state of emergency expires April 20. The House of Representatives last week passed a bill that would extend the governor’s emergency powers until May 20.

“The governor has used his powers thoughtfully and judiciously throughout the past year, and that approach will not change,” said Max Reiss, the governor’s communications director.

Overall, the opinion was a victory for Lamont and an impediment to the plaintiffs in a different case challenging a requirement that children wear masks in class as a COVID precaution.

To uphold Lamont’s exercise of emergency powers, McDonald explored the origins and revisions of Connecticut’s public health and civil preparedness laws, as well as how they intersect with presidential powers in disasters.

There is no mention of contagions in the relevant state laws, but the court relied on the plain-language meaning of “catastrophe,” the unquestioned cost of the pandemic in human and economic loss, and how state and federal disaster declarations interact.

Exhibit C, Casey v. Lamont

The challenge was brought by the owner of Casey’s Pub in Milford, closed by Lamont’s order since March.

Connecticut law defines ‘‘major disaster’’ as ‘‘any catastrophe including, but not limited to, any hurricane, tornado, storm, high water, wind-driven water, tidal wave, tsunami, earthquake, volcanic eruption, landslide, mud- slide, snowstorm or drought, or, regardless of cause, any fire, flood, explosion, or man-made disaster in any part of this state that … in the determination of the President, causes damage of sufficient severity and magnitude to warrant major disaster assistance” under the federal Stafford Act.

McDonald quoted Trump’s declaration under the Stafford Act that the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on Connecticut “are of sufficient severity and magnitude to warrant a major disaster declaration.”

Five words before the enumerated disasters in Connecticut law are crucial, in the court’s view. Those words are  ‘‘including, but not limited to.’’

“By including this phrase, the legislature evinced its intent that a ‘major disaster’ not be limited in scope to the enumerated events, as the plaintiffs contend,” the court said. 

“Moreover, it would be absurd for the statutory scheme to be interpreted such that the governor could declare a civil preparedness emergency for an event such as a snowstorm but not for the worst pandemic that has impacted the state in more than one century,” the court said. “We decline to construe the meaning of ‘major disaster’ in such a manner.”

By any rationale measure, McDonald wrote, the pandemic has been a catastrophe, noting it “has caused vast disruption to everyday life, and it has had a devastating impact on our economy.” He referenced a CT Mirror story about a University of Connecticut assessment that the state economy might not fully recover until 2030.

The court also rejected arguments that the legislature had wrongly delegated its authority to the executive. McDonald citied Connecticut case law, including the court’s previous rejection of a UConn faculty union’s challenge to the legislature granting a governor the authority during one year to make unilateral budget cuts of up to 5%.

The legislature had granted Lamont broad authority.

“A broad grant of authority, however, is not the same as limitless or standardless authority. As we have explained, although the General Assembly may not delegate its ‘law-making’ function, it may delegate ‘some considerable segment of its legislative authority.’”

McDonald noted that in a challenge to the California governor’s restriction during the pandemic on the number of people permitted in houses of worship, “Chief Justice John Roberts emphasized the need for elected leaders to have broad authority to respond to rapidly evolving emergencies.”

Sign up for CT Mirror's free daily news summary.

Free to Read. Not Free to Produce.

The Connecticut Mirror is a nonprofit newsroom. 90% of our revenue comes from people like you. If you value our reporting please consider making a donation. You'll enjoy reading CT Mirror even more knowing you helped make it happen.

YES, I'LL DONATE TODAY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Mark Pazniokas is the Capitol Bureau Chief and a co-founder of CT Mirror. He is a frequent contributor to WNPR, a former state politics writer for The Hartford Courant and Journal Inquirer, and contributor for The New York Times.

SEE WHAT READERS SAID

RELATED STORIES
New Britain residents weren’t getting vaccinated. So city officials got creative.
by Dave Altimari

The city's efforts are a microcosm of what is happening across the country as officials struggle to vaccinate vulnerable residents.

CT’s vaccine advisory group is on hold as members ask what’s next
by Jenna Carlesso

Dozens of experts are on the sidelines. Some say their work is done; others say they could have done more.

His reward for civic heroism during the pandemic: a $16,000 tax bill
by Paul Stern

A Mansfield teacher raised some $41,000 to feed families during the pandemic. To the IRS it was "personal income."

Lamont closed the restaurants. Now he is their promoter.
by Mark Pazniokas

A year after Gov. Ned Lamont banned indoor dining due to COVID-19, the industry has welcomed him as its savior.

Lamont faults CDC on J&J vaccine pause: ‘I would have handled it differently’
by Mark Pazniokas

Gov. Ned Lamont and other governors expressed dismay to the White House over pausing the Johnson & Johnson vaccine.

Support Our Work

Show your love for great stories and outstanding journalism.

$
Select One
  • Monthly
  • Yearly
  • Once
Artpoint painter
CT ViewpointsCT Artpoints
Opinion College students in Connecticut should be vaccinated now
by Dayna Vadala

If the state of Connecticut wants its institutions of higher learning to return to normal in the fall, it’s going to have to get shots into the arms of the students.

Opinion Connecticut, be a International leader against hair discrimination among children
by Faith D. Crittenden, Jade A. Anderson, MD, and Whitney L. Stuard

On March 1, 2020, Connecticut became the eighth state to pass the Crown Act, a national legislative movement that recognizes natural hair and cultural headwear discrimination as a form of racial discrimination in the workplace. While we are  in strong support and advocate for this law, it is important to recognize the limitations of the Crown Act and how it can be improved upon in future policy.

Opinion Three lessons for schools across America from Secretary Cardona’s hometown
by Mark Benigni

Over the past decade, Meriden Public Schools -- where U.S. Education Secretary Miguel Cardona served as assistant superintendent -- has become a unique laboratory for new ideas that push the boundaries of what is possible in public education. And many of those ideas have paid off.

Opinion A healthcare system too broken to fix
by Sosena Kedebe MD

On March 25, the White house announced that it was going to invest over $6 billion in health centers that are funded through the Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) in order to expand COVID-19 vaccinations and other health services provided to vulnerable populations. As a chief medical officer for a health center that is strained to reach some of the most disenfranchised patient population in Hartford, this was great news. Yet there was a part of me that took the news with a deep concern. Why you might ask?

Artwork Grand guidance
by Anne:Gogh

In a world of systemic oppression aimed towards those of darker skintones – representation matters. We are more than our equity elusive environments, more than numbers in a prison and much more than victims of societal dispositions. This piece depicts a melanated young man draped in a cape ascending high above multiple forms of oppression. […]

Artwork Shea
by Anthony Valentine

Shea is a story about race and social inequalities that plague America. It is a narrative that prompts the question, “Do you know what it’s like to wake up in new skin?”

Artwork The Declaration of Human Rights
by Andres Chaparro

Through my artwork I strive to create an example of ideas that reflect my desire to raise social consciousness, and cultural awareness. Jazz music is the catalyst to all my work, and plays a major influence in each piece of work.”

Artwork ‘A thing of beauty. Destroy it forever’
by Richard DiCarlo | Derby

During times like these it’s often fun to revisit something familiar and approach things with a different slant. I have been taking some Pop culture and Art masterpieces and applying the vintage 1960’s and 70’s classic figures (Fisher Price, little people) to the make an amusing pieces. Here is my homage to Fisher -Price, Yellow […]

Twitter Feed
A Twitter List by CTMirror

Engage

  • Reflections Tickets & Sponsorships
  • Events
  • Donate
  • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Submit to Viewpoints
  • Submit to ArtPoints
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Commenting Guidelines
  • Legal Notices
  • Contact Us

About

  • About CT Mirror
  • Announcements
  • Board
  • Staff
  • Sponsors and Funders
  • Donors
  • Friends of CT Mirror
  • History
  • Financial
  • Policies
  • Strategic Plan

Opportunity

  • Advertising and Sponsorship
  • Speaking Engagements
  • Use of Photography
  • Work for Us

Go Deeper

  • Steady Habits Podcast
  • Economic Indicator Dashboard
  • Five Things

The Connecticut News Project, Inc. 1049 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06105. Phone: 860-218-6380

© Copyright 2021, The Connecticut News Project. All Rights Reserved. Website by Web Publisher PRO